Student-led investigation into missing dues leads to faculty adviser's ouster
By: Joseph Fisher, Senior Editor
A longtime faculty member was removed as adviser to the Public Relations Student Society of America (PRSSA) after money turned over to her for student dues went missing.
Dr. Maria Mendoza-Enright, associate professor of mass communications, was removed after a heated verbal confrontation with a PRSSA student board member last semester.
The board member, who requested anonymity, reached out to PRSSA’s national headquarters last semester to see if the organization had received the students’ dues. Officials at the headquarters informed him that no members from the Bloomsburg University chapter were registered.
“I knew something wasn’t right,” says the board member, who started digging through records in the Community Government Association (CGA) Husky Fund shortly after he was elected to a top office in PRSSA in fall 2012. The Husky Fund is an account used by on-campus organizations to keep track of revenue and expenditures.
The board member estimates around $700 was missing in total.
More than 10 students paid $65 in cash for their dues, $50 of which was to be turned over to nationals. The other $15 was to go to the Husky Fund, to be used by the local chapter. Several students confirmed that Mendoza insisted they give her cash rather than a check.
Dr. Mendoza, rather than the student treasurer of the organization, took charge of collecting the funds that were given to her at the beginning of last semester.
But according to an email from PRSSA headquarters, those funds were never received. The student board member then approached Dr. Mendoza in her on-campus office, where he said she immediately became defensive and insisted she had made the credit card payment.
“Her finger was in my face and she was yelling ‘How dare you accuse me,’” said the board member. “She made herself seem like the victim.”
After Mendoza told the student she had already sent in the dues in one lump sum payment on her credit card, he said he responded, “You’re a liar. Stop lying.”
Within hours of that 40-minute screaming match, the board member received a phone call from the secretary in the department of mass communications, who told him the chair wanted to meet with him. Dr. George Agbango was appointed interim chair of the mass communications department in spring 2011. Mendoza, who had been chair, was removed by the president.
The board member met the next day with Dr. Agbango, a longtime personal friend of Dr. Mendoza. The board member said Agbango praised him for his leadership and said the department would be handling the situation. Agbango also asked the student to name a new adviser. He chose Dr. David Magolis, assistant professor of mass communications, who is the current interim adviser of PRSSA.
“She wanted to give the money to [the board member] all along,” said Dr. Agbango in an interview last week. “It was an example of poor communication between him and Dr. Mendoza.”
When asked the reason for her ouster, Agbango said, “Dr. Mendoza was overextended,” and did not elaborate.
The board member informed Sydney Yarnell, PRSSA treasurer, and LaShae Green, another PRSSA board member about the situation. He said all three were committed to the effort of recovering the funds.
The student board member said that shortly after the Agbango meeting, Dr. Mendoza wrote a personal check and gave it to one of the other board members. She wrote the check despite her original insistence that she had already paid the dues in one lump sum on her credit card
Neither the students, nor Mendoza, revealed the exact amount of the check.
Yarnell said she never questioned any issues regarding the dues until the board member discovered missing funds.
“I never looked at the statements before this year … but obviously none of the money made it into the account.”
Green said she was under the impression that the university was investigating the entire matter. The board member leading the investigation said he went to Nawal Bonomo, assistant to the dean of the College of Liberal Arts, immediately following his confrontation with Mendoza in the fall 2012 to apprise her of the matter.
The board member said he assumed after that meeting the university would investigate.
But Dr. James Brown, dean of the College of Liberal Arts was interviewed last week and denied knowing anything about a new adviser, missing funds or any problems connected to PRSSA.
“This is the first I am hearing about it,” said Dr. Brown. “… But it sounds as if the chairperson tried to fix the problem within the department, which is what I would expect.”
Several officials connected with this story discouraged a student reporter from looking into the issue.
Interviewed last week, Mendoza declined to discuss the handling of the money or her replacement as adviser except to say, “The money was put in … this issue has been resolved.”
Dr. Agbango insisted there was no controversy because of the check Mendoza turned over to PRSSA.
“That was the resolution,” said Agbango.
The student leading the investigation said the matter was a lesson in accountability.
“I care about things being fair and just,” said the student, “and there is no place for something like this [behavior].”